State of New York Sued Over Unfair Taxes by Trucking Association

State of New York Sued Over Unfair Taxes by Trucking Association

On October 8th, 2013 Owner-Operators Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA)  filed a class action lawsuit in the Supreme Court of New York. The lawsuit challenges the constitutionality of NY’s imposition of highway taxes. With this lawsuit OOIDA is seeking to represent all interstate motor carriers who are subject to the fees and are not based in New York.

[av_button label=’Read the Complaint’ link=’manually,http://www.ooida.com/CourtActions/NYHwyUseTax/Complaint.pdf’ link_target=’_blank’ color=’theme-color-subtle’ custom_bg=’#444444′ custom_font=’#ffffff’ size=’small’ position=’left’ icon_select=’yes’ icon=’56’ av_uid=’av-4ydzsc’]

New York imposes a $15 fee for a certificate of registration and a $4 decal charge for all trucks that use New York highways even if they are not based in New York. Not paying the fee can result in stiff fines and even potential impound of a truck. Section 502 of the NY Tax Law requires that each carrier apply to the DTF for a certificate of registration for each motor vehicle operated on public highway in the state.

Because out-of-state trucks travel relatively few miles within New York when compared to in-state trucks, OOIDA argues that it places an undue burden on interstate commerce through a higher per mile tax rate. Accordingly this is a violation of the Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 3. If OOIDA wins the lawsuit it is asking the court to stop the state from collecting the fees, as well as issue refunds to the out-of-state carriers that paid the fees in the past.

I feel that the particular method that the state uses to collect the taxes is burdensome to smaller trucking companies and car haulers; yet at the same time I believe that the state has the right to collect revenue from carriers.

Do you think the State of New York has the right to charge the tax? Comment bellow.

[av_hr av_uid=’av-39ax4c’]

About the Author: Alex Marinov

4b586afda56310883a7cce9efc036e95?s=72&d=wavatar&r=pg
Alex Marinov is the president of RCG Logistics LLC, with years experience in the shipping and freight industry. His main interest include sustainable building design, video production and automobiles.

Author

4b586afda56310883a7cce9efc036e95?s=54&d=wavatar&r=pg
Posted by
Alex Marinov
Post Date
10/18/2013

Recent Posts

Car Shipping Quote

Pick Up From*
Hidden

Deliver To*
Hidden

Help Center

Recent Blogs

  • Are you considering relocating to another state? Here are some key steps to take into consideration to make sure your relocation goes smoothly. How To Relocate To Another State? A Checklist for Moving Out of State Many people get excited at the prospect of moving to a new state, but [...]

    By Published On: 11/21/2022Categories: Relocation
  • Have you question "How To Negotiate A Relocation Package?" it is essential to calculate the costs. This will help you understand what you need and what you can afford. How To Negotiate A Relocation Package? Depending on the distance between your workplace and your new job, your employer may provide [...]

    By Published On: 11/08/2022Categories: Relocation
  • Are you part of a company that relies on a commercial fleet of vehicles in Hurricane Ian-affected parts of Florida and South Carolina? Are you struggling to coordinate commercial vehicle transport or unsure of what to do about inoperable vehicles? If your answer to any of these questions was yes, [...]

    By Published On: 10/25/2022Categories: Car Shipping, Hurricane Ian